Dr. Ben Braddock, who posts on X as @GraduatedBen, wrote in September 2024 that “You can see a warm LED and think it’s fine because of the perceived color temperature. But take a slow-motion video and you’ll see the flicker. This is very bad for the brain.” His post includes a slow-motion video, and you can run the test he describes at home this afternoon.
Why LEDs flicker
The U.S. Department of Energy explains that older bulbs kept glowing between electrical pulses. An incandescent filament stays hot, and a fluorescent tube has a phosphor coating. An LED has no such persistence, so its light follows its electronics. Those electronics, called the driver, are built in different ways. A good driver holds the light steady, and a poor one can let the light swing by as much as 100 percent, from fully on to fully off, according to DOE.
Waveform Lighting, a lighting maker, describes two common causes. One is leftover ripple from alternating current, which can make a bulb with simple electronics flicker 100 to 120 times a second. The other is pulse-width modulation, which dims an LED by switching it on and off quickly, so a bulb that looks half bright is off half the time. Color temperature has nothing to do with it, which is Braddock’s point about warm bulbs.
What the research says
DOE says offices lit by older fluorescent fixtures with strong flicker saw more headaches and weaker task performance, and that flicker effects range from “uncomfortable or distracting to harmful or (rarely) dangerous.” DOE adds that people differ widely in what they see and that researchers have not settled the thresholds. The IEEE’s 2015 recommended practice on LED flicker, which IEEE now lists as “Inactive-Reserved,” cites research that fluorescent flicker at 100 Hz caused headaches at a modulation depth of about 35 percent. It also notes that visible low-frequency flicker can trigger seizures in sensitive people.
I read Braddock’s “very bad for the brain” as his own wording. The sources I found describe headaches, eyestrain and, rarely, seizures in sensitive people, and they do not claim every flickering bulb harms everyone. If you get frequent headaches, a doctor can look at all the possible causes.
The phone test
Open your phone camera, switch to slow-motion video and record the bulb for two or three seconds. Waveform Lighting says a steady bulb stays steady on playback, while a flickering one shows repeated flashing. Check the bulb at full brightness and again at the dimmer settings you use, since some bulbs flicker only when dimmed.
This is a screening test. DOE’s testing of handheld meters found that a smartphone flicker app did not perform as well as dedicated meters, though it can help you spot a problem. Some newer phones also smooth out the banding that used to show on camera, so a clean video is a good sign, not proof.
Buying better bulbs
In a screw-in bulb the driver is inside the bulb, so a flickering bulb has to be replaced.
The good news is that the Trump administration is fighting to bring the old incandescent bulb back. Energy officials told Congress in September they won’t ‘centrally plan which lighting technologies people can use,’ and Sen. Mike Lee’s bill to end the ban has cleared committee. Until Congress finishes the job, though, LEDs are what’s on the shelf, so it pays to pick good ones.
Look for bulbs that publish flicker data. California’s Title 24 energy code defines “reduced flicker operation” as less than 30 percent flicker below 200 Hz, measured at both full output and 20 percent output, and the ENERGY STAR lamp specification added flicker reporting in version 2.1. Test one bulb of a new brand before you buy a case. If you dim, use a dimmable bulb on a dimmer made for LEDs, since The Department of Energy says flicker usually happens when an LED bulb that isn’t made for dimming is put on a dimmer switch. If you have dimmers, look for ‘dimmable’ on the box.
